E49: Okay, but... turkeys!
Release Date: Nov 19, 2026When you picture a turkey, you probably see the bird on the platter, not the lean, wary one that sleeps in the treetops. Dr. Mike Chamberlain, the National Wild Turkey Federation Endowed Chair at the University of Georgia, has put GPS tags on thousands of wild turkeys, and he talks about how the wild turkey differs from the domestic bird you’re probably more familiar with on Thanksgiving.
Transcript
In this episode
- How the wild turkey differs from the farm bird on the Thanksgiving table, and the other turkey species, the ocellated turkey of the Yucatan
- The skull cap, snood, wattle and caruncles of a tom's face, and why turkeys gobble
- Shock gobbling: why a tom gobbles back at an owl, a car door or an elk bugle
- How wild turkeys came back from near extinction, why some populations are declining again, and how often their nests fail
Scott Taylor: When I say picture a turkey, what do you see? A big white bird in a farmyard? A platter on the Thanksgiving table? I'd guess most of you don't picture a lean brown bird slipping through the forest. That's because turkeys, like chickens, stay tuned for that episode, were domesticated. And the domestic bird has taken over our imaginations. There are only two species of turkey in the entire world, and both live in the Americas. One is the wild turkey of North America. The other is the ocellated turkey of the Yucatan Peninsula. The white birds pardoned at the White House every November are domesticated wild turkeys. They're much heavier than their wild relatives and far worse at flying. Quick vocabulary lesson before we go on. Adult males are toms, females are hens, young males are jakes, and baby turkeys are poults. About 800 years ago, in what is now Mesa Verde, Colorado, the ancestral Puebloans kept turkeys in pens. They wove blankets from thousands of turkey feathers wrapped around yucca cord. For centuries, they don't seem to have eaten the birds much. Turkeys were for feathers, warmth, and ceremony, and then only later became dinner when deer got scarce. Meanwhile, more than a thousand miles south, people in Mesoamerica were keeping turkeys of their own. The DNA suggests these weren't simply the same birds traded north, so the turkey may have been domesticated more than once for completely different reasons. Spanish colonizers shipped the Mesoamerican birds to Europe, and their descendants later sailed back across the Atlantic with European settlers. Even the name is a mix-up. In the 1500s, English speakers called an African bird the helmeted guineafowl a turkey-cock because it reached Europe through Ottoman trade. The American bird looked close enough to borrow the name and it stuck. In Turkish, meanwhile, the bird is called hindi, meaning Indian. So, a bird from Mexico is named after Turkey in English and after India in Turkey. Which brings us to the topic of today's episode: Okay, but... turkeys! To help us unpack that, I'm joined by Dr. Mike Chamberlain, the National Wild Turkey Federation Endowed Chair at the University of Georgia. After the break, Mike explains how different a wild turkey is from the one on your plate and how a bird that nearly disappeared made its comeback. We get into why some populations are slipping again and we find out how hunters might be changing populations in surprising ways. Stay tuned.
Scott Taylor: Welcome back to the podcast, everyone. I'm really excited to have Mike with us today to talk about turkeys. Thanks for joining us, Mike.
Mike Chamberlain: Glad to be with you.
Scott Taylor: I think when most people think of a turkey, they think of something akin to a Butterball. Certainly they think of Thanksgiving. Could we start with just, you know, what a wild turkey is actually like compared to these domestic turkeys we're probably more familiar with and how different it is from that Thanksgiving table bird?
Mike Chamberlain: Yeah, for sure. I mean, a wild turkey could not be any fundamentally different than the Butterball that you buy at Costco. Wild turkeys are extremely wary. They make a living by being able to detect danger and escape it. The turkey that you and I consume is laden intentionally with fat. They're large. Their breasts are large because the idea is to produce meat. And in reality, a wild turkey is anything but fat. They are lean with very little fat stored on their body. Their muscles are very dark and their legs, unlike what you and I consume at Thanksgiving, almost red to the point like a waterfowl breast would be because those legs are how they evade danger. So they're very lean, gangly, not the rotund white blob that you see in a commercial situation.
Scott Taylor: And they can fly pretty well. I mean, they fly up to roost every night, right? Whereas I think a lot of people think, well, and some domestic turkeys are just so heavy with that artificially selected giant breast muscle that they probably can't fly very well. But wild turkeys can fly pretty well, right?
Mike Chamberlain: For sure, yeah. And wild turkeys are adapted for short flights. I mean, they're not agile enough, and their bodies are large relative to their wings. As you know, as a bird guy, they're adapted to explode off the ground and then sail to avoid danger. But yes, they do. They sleep in trees at night to avoid predators, and they have to fly up to those trees.
Scott Taylor: Yeah, a couple years ago, the American Ornithological Society conference was in Estes Park, Colorado, And the ponderosa pine tree outside the cabin was the turkey roost. And so the first evening we noticed these turkeys all appearing and then all of a sudden appearing up in the tree. And the next morning we saw exactly what you said, that sailing flight as they left the roost to go down and start foraging again. But it's just unexpected, I guess, if you haven't really seen turkeys in the wild, to see them up in a tree.
Mike Chamberlain: And it's a big bird to see sailing around. I mean, particularly the toms, the males. I mean, that 20-plus pound bird. You don't usually see a lot of 20 plus pound birds flying around or sailing around. So it is kind of cool to see them in flight.
Scott Taylor: It's super cool. Yeah, it's super cool. I was really happy that we lucked out and had a cabin near the roosting tree. A tom's face has a lot of parts to it that do different things. Can you walk us through what the snood, the wattle, and the caruncles are and what each one is for?
Mike Chamberlain: Yes, so if you look at a male turkey in the spring, you know, they're red, white and blue. Their heads and neck are red, white and blue, which I often tell people, you know, our battle flag has that coloration, and you know, the wild turkey is, to me, is America's bird. Because of that. Yeah, well, there's a debate about that. So yeah, so if you start at the top male's head is white, and that's the skull cap, It's dissipating heat, brightly colored white in the spring, so it's attracting attention. You're a turkey hunter, particularly in forested or shadier areas, most hunters will tell you that's the first thing you see when a male is approaching you is that white skull cap, it sticks out. You move down into the side of their face, their cheeks, if you will. You start seeing that the head color changes to blue and reds. The snood, which is this fleshy protuberance that hangs off the end of their beak. It serves multiple functions immune response is one thing.
Mike Chamberlain: But you often see that the snood elongates when the bird is excited and very content and the snood contracts when the bird is alarmed. There's also evidence showing, research evidence showing clearly that birds with longer snoods tend to be more fit. Their parasite loads are much lower. And so that's the snood. You then move under their chin and you see this loose skin called the dewlap. It's not a wattle like with a chicken, but it's called a dewlap, and that's also dissipation type function. Then you move into the caruncles, which are the bumpy, fleshy, red things at the base of their neck where the feathers start. And the caruncles are also a blood flow, heat dissipation item, but when they become engorged with blood, they glow red.
Scott Taylor: They can really change color fast, eh? Like, yeah.
Mike Chamberlain: They do, very, within a second, they change colors. And so what you see when a male is excited and he's displaying, you see this color combination. That is very, it's dramatic, and it draws attention, which is one reason why many of the battle flags across the globe, across countries, are red, white and blue in some type of sequence that commands attention at a distance. And so yeah, that's, their heads are really interesting. Yeah.
Scott Taylor: Yeah. Yeah. I think the speed at which it can all change is, I think, shocking when you first see like a video that shows how quickly the snood can elongate or the color of their caruncles can change. So wild turkeys, I mean, one reason many people may not think about them is kind of their history in North America where they were nearly wiped out. Like I don't remember ever seeing a wild turkey where I grew up until much later in life. And then they were very successfully reintroduced in places. So can you talk us through kind of what happened to these wild turkeys, why they got rare and now are common again?
Mike Chamberlain: The history of the wild turkey is pretty interesting. They were largely extirpated from across their geographic range because of deforestation and overharvest, market hunting. And so what you ended up with historically was just a few pockets of turkeys that were left. And so in the 1960s and 70s, you started seeing state agencies working cooperatively, trying to trap and transport turkeys, basically capture wild birds with rocket or cannon nets and transport those birds and release them into vacant habitats where there were no turkeys currently living. But then in the 1980s, it really accelerated. You started seeing state agencies that were willing to essentially trade. And so what a state would do is we will give you 12 turkeys. And in return, we want... 50 grouse or and so there was this bartering system and you also saw the creation of the National Wild Turkey Federation and what the National Wild Turkey Federation started doing is they served as a conduit to allow agencies to trap and transport birds across state lines and to offer financial incentives for doing so. So in other words, all of the state agencies agreed that, for instance, a wild turkey was worth $500. And so I'll just create an example. Georgia pays Tennessee for X number of turkeys. They send that money to NWTF and then NWTF sends that money to Tennessee. So the NWTF created this system where restoration could really accelerate because you could legally take birds from one state and move them to another state. And so during the late 80s and particularly the early 1990s, you started seeing states really trap and transport a bunch of birds because they were able to obtain turkeys from different sources and so if you look for instance if you come out if you go out west you start you see situations where states if you look at a range map of the wild turkey you'll see situations where a particular state notes that they have multiple subspecies present within one state and the reason for that is simple it that state was taking turkeys from multiple sources which included different subspecies and that's why you see that such a complicated range map when you look at the subspecies level of wild turkey because agencies were literally taking birds from wherever they could get birds And so when restoration was occurring, agencies, kind of blurred those lines, right? So for instance, Rio Grande, if you look now, wild turkeys did not even occur in states like Oregon. And if you go to Oregon now, you'll see that there are multiple subspecies. And so like, for instance, the Rio Grande wild turkey, which is a Southern Plains bird, is living in Oregon.
Scott Taylor: And it's doing okay.
Mike Chamberlain: Way outside of a completely different landscape, yeah.
Scott Taylor: Yeah, that's such a wet forested landscape compared to where they evolved. And they're doing well in Oregon. Like that subspecies has been able to adapt. Yeah. Huh. That's so interesting. So why do they gobble instead of sing? And what's the deal with shock gobbling?
Mike Chamberlain: Okay, so by default, the gobble is a, if you look on a sonogram, it's this explosive call that is designed to pierce the environment. It's designed, unlike a bird that's calling, turkeys will gobble.
Scott Taylor: Mm hmm. That makes sense.
Mike Chamberlain: At a sound that is hundreds and hundreds of meters away. And you can hear a turkey gobble for a dramatic distance, whereas a cardinal calling that call gets attenuated in the environment it gets chewed up right so you can't hear the cardinal but so far well in the turkey world because of their mating system they use a mating system that's kind of akin to leks where you see more exploded leks in the eastern subspecies and more classical leks as you get out west And so this is a bird that needs to project a sound a very long distance in some instances to attract the attention of female and get her to come to him. And so that's why they gobble rather than call. The shock gobble is interesting. If you look at, and what this idea is that there are sounds in the environment that cause a turkey male to gobble in response to it, not just a hen calling. There are these other things like an owl hooting, a gunshot in the distance, a car door slamming in some instances, a coyote howling, an elk bugling.
Scott Taylor: Oh, that's going on right now. I was listening to elk yesterday morning. Yeah.
Mike Chamberlain: Yeah, and so what we've seen, and you think, well, why in the world would a bird respond to something like that? If you plot that sound on a sonogram, it falls in the exact same frequency band as the gobble. And birds will often gobble to each other, right? And so you have a turkey that's out there in location A, and he gobbles, and the turkey in location B hears him and gobbles back at him. And so it makes sense when you think about it that way, that if it's in the same frequency band, as soon as he detects the sound, it causes a reaction and he gobbles in response to it.
Scott Taylor: I would love to hear a turkey gobble in response to an elk bugling. That would be amazing. But it does.
Mike Chamberlain: I hunt with a group in Northeastern Wyoming every year. And one of the locator calls, which is like a call that you would use to try to get a turkey to gobble to you don't know he's there, right? You're trying to find a bird to go hunt. And Kenny will typically use an elk bugle to try to shock the bird. And it's really cool too because it's like, bugle goes out and you hear the bird gobbling response. It's like weird. It's really weird.
Scott Taylor: Yeah, that's so weird. I would love to hear that. Yeah. Oh, man. And other than the wild turkey, There's just one other species of turkey, right? And it's in the Yucatan Peninsula.
Mike Chamberlain: That's right, the ocellated turkey.
Scott Taylor: The ocellated turkey. Most people have never heard of the ocellated turkey, but it's a pretty crazy looking bird.
Mike Chamberlain: They are. They are very unique and they have an interesting vocalization that's completely different than the wild turkey.
Scott Taylor: So turkeys have had this really interesting history in North America where colonization and European settlers really drove populations to very low numbers. And then conservation has brought them back to really high numbers and kind of mixed up these subspecies. But numbers are falling again in certain places, or you can tell me if it's everywhere. And you've spent a lot of your career trying to figure out why. So where does the science stand on how wild turkeys are doing in North America?
Mike Chamberlain: Well, it varies dramatically depending on where you are located. So back around 2008, 2009, my lab, along with a number of state agencies, started documenting what appeared to be broad scale regional declines in turkey abundance and productivity across the Southeastern United States. And so if you look at the declines now, they include all of the Southeastern United states such as Oklahoma, Kansas, Nebraska, Ohio, states that are seeing clearly that Turkey populations have declined in some cases quite dramatically over the past decade. And I'll give you an example. Here in Georgia, if you just fly a commercial flight across the Piedmont, which is the center of the state that dominates most of the state, From 30,000 foot above, it looks like there's a lot of green stuff down there. There's a lot of forest left. But when you zoom in local areas, particularly within counties and across counties, you will see things such as a dramatic loss or conversion of hardwood forest. Those hardwood forests have been converted to pine dominated forests for wood fiber production, or they've been altered or completely lost to suburban development, urbanization. And that scenario is playing out everywhere. It's kind of death by a thousand cuts.
Scott Taylor: Turkeys are one of these species that they lay a lot of eggs per clutch, right? Typically.
Mike Chamberlain: They do. Yeah, it averages 10 to 12, you know, for the first clutch. And they also will re-nest multiple times if they lose their first nest. And so they try to be prolific. The problem is that the success of their nest, as with many ground nesting birds, is lower than you would want.
Scott Taylor: Yeah. What is it? Like you've tracked hundreds of females' turkeys. I assume at least part of them are being tracked during the breeding season. Like what is typical nest success for a turkey? Like you said, they nest on the ground. There's lots of things on the ground that like to eat eggs, like raccoons and coyotes and these other predators that I'm sure are a problem. But yeah, what's typical nesting success for a female turkey?
Mike Chamberlain: My lab, along with several colleagues, we've captured and put GPS units on thousands of females On average, across much of the South, you're looking at a nest success of about 20 to 25%, meaning 75% of clutches fail.
Scott Taylor: And that's at the clutch stage. That's not even the turkey baby growing into an adult turkey, right?
Mike Chamberlain: The problem with turkey is not just getting the egg to hatch. Juveniles or the young, the offspring, they're called poults, like chicks. They really have a difficult go of it the first few weeks of life because when they hatch, they are covered by natal down. They can't thermoregulate. They have to sleep on the ground with mom at night and so during the first about two weeks they they're stuck on the ground at night and what we see with our GPS telemetry because we also have accelerometers within the GPS unit so we can see very clearly when a predation event occurs You see a lot of broods get killed at night. The brood itself, the poults get killed at night by nocturnal predators such as, for instance, coyotes. They'll disrupt the brood at night. Turkeys have very poor night vision because of the rod and cone structure in their eyes. And so it's hard to be a young turkey once they get a few weeks old and they can start flying making short flights into shrubs and trees that that's where their survival starts to really increase but when we look across many of our study sites we're seeing that about 30 to 35 percent of the brood the collective group of poults that mom has about 35% of those broods make it to one month of age. And so if you combine those two, the nest success value and the brood success value together, you see that less than 10% of nests produce a poult that survives.
Scott Taylor: That's pretty low.
Mike Chamberlain: It is low, yeah.
Scott Taylor: Yeah. Yeah. I know there was a turkey family by my cabin a couple of years ago. And across that first two week period, it went from, I think there were seven chicks that I counted at first. And then for the rest of the summer, I saw the mom with one. So just one made it through that. And so we've been talking about conservation, but also hunting And you work with hunters and you study the consequences of hunting for turkey populations. And so, of course, hunters are shooting and eating turkeys. And I've had wild turkey before. And as long as it's prepared properly, it's quite delicious, actually. And you found, though, that they're not just removing turkeys from a population. They're kind of changing which turkeys survive, talk through that research and kind of what's happening to these wild turkey populations that are experiencing hunting pressure.
Mike Chamberlain: Yeah so first I'm a fanatical turkey hunter myself which is I know some listeners may go well that's the ultimate paradox right you know how can you how can you claim to cherish conservation of this bird and seek to kill it I counter that by saying you know the reason that we have wild turkeys in North America is largely because of Hunters drove that restoration engine. We put money in the state agency coffers that drive management efforts at state and federal levels. And wild turkey, as you say, is quite delicious when it's prepared properly. And there's a number of ways to... Oh, no, you can't do that. You'll end up with really dry, tough stuff. Yeah.
Scott Taylor: When it's prepared properly don't cook it like you'd cook your Thanksgiving turkey that would be very dry yeah.
Mike Chamberlain: But that said, what you've seen over the past few decades in particular is turkey hunting, particularly in the spring. So turkeys can legally be hunted, depending on what state you live in either the fall or the spring or both. Spring hunting is dramatically more popular. And the reason for that is The males are displaying. They're gobbling. They're interactive. You call to them. You try to get them to approach you. You're simulating being a female. And so it's a very kind of one-on-one game, me versus the male turkey. Spring hunting has become much more popular over the past few decades and there's now an entire industry framed around spring turkey hunting and so what our research has been doing has clearly shown that harvest is a select it's a selective harvest of males which isn't surprising if you think about it I mean you not all males behave the same right we're clearly seeing that we're seeing that there's no such thing as an average male wild turkey there are some that are very risky in their behavior there are some that are very shy in their behavior there's some that move a lot there's some that don't move much at all there's some that vocalize a lot they get shot There's some that vocalize very little, if any. And so, yep. And what we're seeing.
Scott Taylor: Oh if any really hmm.
Mike Chamberlain: As an aside, we're also fitting males with GPS units that have an audio logger on them. And the audio logger records all ambient sound for one hour every morning right around sunrise. So when they're gobbling, we can hear the individual bird gobbling. Well, what we also can hear is we can hear them drumming, right? Because the audio logger is right on their back. And so even, let's just say you have five males that are in the same population. At one extreme across an entire month, male one may only gobble 10 or 15 times in that one hour. Male five gobbles 500 times in that time.
Scott Taylor: That's so much variation.
Mike Chamberlain: Male one, that doesn't gobble much, he may, for instance, drum almost constantly. Male five may drum rarely. And there's everything in between. And so there appears to be a number of strategies that males are taking. But what we've seen to your original question is harvest is indeed very selective in the turkey world. And it has us wondering whether we are selecting for or against certain traits such as... vocalizing a lot are we selectively harvesting males that tend to vocalize more and if so are we going to essentially create a population down the road that behaves differently than the population does now and it does appear very quite plausible that will be yes the turkeys will get more difficult to hunt 100%.
Scott Taylor: Well, that's how selection works. I mean, it makes me think of this amazing story. I was just at a conference here in Colorado and Robin Tinghitella, she's a professor at University of Denver. They study this cricket and fly interaction where there's these crickets on the Hawaiian Islands, Teleogryllus oceanicus. And there's an introduced fly, Ormia ochracea. I might've said that wrong. But anyways, the fly listens to the crickets and then it parasitizes. It's a parasitoid. So it lays its eggs on the singing males and it finds where the singing males are because they're vocalizing. And then the consequence is death. Like the fly will then, the larvae eat the cricket. And it's led to the evolution of silent crickets. So now there's whole populations of these crickets and like crickets, like turkeys are vocal communicators and you're not vocal, I guess, for crickets, but acoustic communicators. And now you have these populations of crickets that are silent and they survive because the fly can't find them. And they're starting to evolve other sounds that seem to be less attractive to the fly. So yeah, strong selection.
Mike Chamberlain: Yeah and if you talk to if you talk to people in the turkey hunting world that have hunted the same spot right the same property or the same plantation or whatever for the last 30 40 years they will almost to a man or woman tell you that turkeys are more quiet now. They gobble much less than they did 20 years ago. And it's to your cricket example. You know, 50 years from now, is there a plausible scenario where there are males that just do not gobble at all? I think yes. That's possible.
Scott Taylor: Yeah, that's so interesting to think about. We are, humans have such, we can exert such strong selection pressures on wild populations. Yeah, that's fascinating. We've reached the part of the show we call That's B.S., or That's Bird Stuff, where we give our guests an opportunity to debunk a myth that ruffles their feathers. So Mike, what do you want to call BS on?
Mike Chamberlain: My big BS would be that turkeys destroy nests of other ground nesting birds. I hear this repeatedly. And also in the same vein, there's this dogma that will not die, that a male, a tom, will find and destroy nests of a female so that she will be receptive to him breeding her again. And neither of those have ever been documented, ever. And as many turkeys that have been studied.
Scott Taylor: Oh I've never heard that.
Mike Chamberlain: That is total BS. Like both of those are total BS.
Scott Taylor: All right. We've called BS on two longstanding myths with turkeys. But yeah, if they've never been documented to the degree that wild turkeys have been studied, then certainly that, yeah, that makes sense. Yeah, pretty safe to say it's BS. Well, I really appreciate you taking the time to come on the podcast and talk all about turkeys with us today. So thank you very much for joining us. I've learned a lot. Yeah.
Mike Chamberlain: Pretty safe to say it's BS, yeah.
Mike Chamberlain: For sure. It's good to talk to you.
Scott Taylor: Birds are dinosaurs, and around here we like our snacks, so we end each episode with a dinosaur nugget. Today's nugget is: the wild turkey is nothing like the bird on your plate. It's lean, wary, and fast on its feet, and it flies up into the trees to sleep every night. It nearly vanished from North America until hunters and wildlife agencies trapped and traded birds across state lines to bring it back. Now, in parts of the Southeast and Midwest, turkeys are declining again from a mix of habitat loss, predators, and other pressures. It's tough from the start. Fewer than 1 in 10 nests produce a poult that survives its first month, and hunters may be changing turkeys too. Toms that gobble a lot get shot more often, so the gobble itself could be getting quieter. That's a wrap on this week's episode, Okay, but... turkeys! For our U.S. listeners, before you stuff yourself this Thanksgiving, follow, subscribe, and leave us a review wherever you listen. And if things get quiet at the dinner table, try a shock gobble. We'll catch you next time. Byeee.
This transcript was generated using AI-assisted transcription and may contain errors or omissions. Please refer to the audio or video episode for the most accurate representation.
Credits
All audio, video, and images in this episode are either original to Okay, But... Birds (© Okay Media, LLC) or used under license/permission from the respective rights holders. Media from the Macaulay Library is used courtesy of the Cornell Lab of Ornithology as follows:
- Wild Turkey audio contributed by James (Jim) Holmes, ML73964601
- Ocellated Turkey audio contributed by Dale Delaney, ML55403
- Wild Turkey audio contributed by Arthur A. Allen and Peter Paul Kellogg, ML23289
- Great Horned Owl audio contributed by James (Jim) Holmes, ML56394991
- Coyote audio contributed by Jay McGowan, ML204867
Additional media used under Creative Commons:
- Pacific Field Cricket photo by Franziska Walz, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0
- Parasitoid fly photo by Jpaur, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0